Naturalizer Women's Kelly Mary Jane Flat

These red Mary Jane flats are exactly what I've wanted for a couple years now. This isn't a stiff or firm leather but a super soft and buttery leather. *Heads-up on sizing* These seem true to shoe size but the width is another matter. I've worn a Medium and very occasionally a Narrow width shoe my entire life. I ordered my usual shoe size in the Medium width and though the length was great, they were so tight it was painful just to try on. I exchanged for same size in a Wide width and they're perfect. If you typically wear a Wide width shoe, it's likely these won't be a comfortable shoe for you. But if you find that the width works for you, these are so comfortable and pretty!

If you wear a wide width, like I do, these may not work out for you. The shoe is pretty, but if you have foot problems or wear a wider width, they will be uncomfortable. I did order a size 7 Wide thinking it would be fine. There is also not much support for the insole. I am disappointed, but I'll keep them to wear for special events, as I'm likely just to be sitting and not walking very much. I would not recommend these shoes if you have any foot or ankle problems.

I found these online and was so excited. The color is spot on, they are genuine leather, they have silver hardware, and the price is right. When they arrived one of those things became untrue. What I thought was silver hardware in the picture is actually pale gold in reality. Nothing against it if this is your thing, but I personally despise this pale gold. Unfortunately, I'll be returning them slightly brokenhearted.

Worked for my extra wide feet, although maybe a bit narrower than expected. The back of the heel is quite stiff and does rub, but hopefully will soften with some more time. I do wish the interior was leather so would breathe better. Overall works for me as a solid office shoe, which was the goal. And I've gotten a few compliments too!

i love these! i wanted to find a mary jane that was comfortable first and foremost, and these definitely fit the bill! they’re so buttery smooth and shaped perfectly to my foot. i got the black leather in my regular size. i wouldn’t wear them on a heavy walking day but they’re great for the office and beyond. 100% recommend!

These are great! I have slightly wide feet and the wide width is perfect! I usually wear size 10 but sized down to a 9 based on reviews. Glad I did. They are a little snug but because they’re real leather they will stretch over time.

I needed a new all-around black shoe to replace a variety of hard- worn pairs. This shoe fit the bill - classic style that can be worn with both pants and skirts. And so comfortable!

Very comfortable shoes. In style with spring shoes.