We want you to be completely delighted with your purchase. If you are not 100% satisfied for any reason upon receiving your order, you may return the item(s) for a full item refund or exchange.
We accept returns and exchanges in store (for both online and in-store orders) or we accept returns by mail (for online orders only) for up to 60 days after an item was purchased. Items must be unworn, in their original packaging and/or box, and accompanied by the Order Confirmation email and packing slip.
From the Party Ready and Wedding Shop collections, this modern classic deliver effortless AM-to-PM comfort. Designed for seamless day-to-night wear, the pointed toe and versatile silhouette offer a refined, forward feel. This timeless pump features a walkable heel, complete with Contour+ Comfort technology for a premium fit and lasting comfort. Designed to the contours of a woman's foot. Available in an inclusive range of sizes and widths for a custom-designed fit and all-day wear. The Beautiful Fit. Est. 1927.
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I'm not a heel person. I hate them, but i needed these for a costume, and I knew naturalizer would have the best options. I received several compliments for these simple black heels, and I broke them in a little before the event. the only reason my feet hurt after 4 hours on them was because of the time and the fact that they were heels - i didn't have any blisters or irritation. as comfy as could be expected. :)
By BonnieL
Rated 2 out of 5
Disappointed in Inconsistent Sizing
I was really excited about this shoe as it is pretty and came in a wide, so I ordered it in black and crème brûlée. The black shoe came and it was pretty, but it was slightly long. Even though it was slightly long, I felt like with ball of foot pads it would be okay. However, the creme brûlée shoe seems like half a size to a whole size too long and I’m disappointed. I would size down but I ordered a 6 wide, and Naturalizer doesn’t offer this shoe in a 5.5 wide shoe. Additionally, the crème brûlée shoe already had creases and wrinkles when it arrived, and after trying on the black pair they also had a crease. Very disappointed after how excited I was. Really beautiful shoe and seems like it would be comfortable if it fit you. However, the material may not be the best and it seems like there are inconsistencies in sizing across colors of the same everly pump. I’m unsure whether to return the crème brûlée ones as I’m not sure if they are defective, and I ordered these shoes because I need them in a week. I have another pair of shoes coming from Naturalizer, in a different style, and I hope those fit. I tried to upload photos but I couldn’t figure out how to let Safari access them. The video option offered was so grainy that it was difficult to see the creases. I’m happy to provide the photos through email or if I’m reached out to.
By Aci1
Rated 4 out of 5
Very comfortable
Found to be very comfortable with the wider shoe option.
By Barb1
Rated 5 out of 5
I love these, they are extremely comfy and I keep rebuying them but they damage very easily.
By Nadu
Rated 5 out of 5
Comfortable and stylish
To not only get a pump that is truly comfortable for wearing during an 8 hr. Workday but is stylish and super flattering to wear is a winner in my book. A classic that I’ll wear season after season!
By LilsterK
Rated 5 out of 5
Comfortable And dressy
The pumps are very comfortable and dressy. I am very happy with the fit. This is my second pair of these.
By Lbyrd
Rated 5 out of 5
Classic pump
Good heel height, rather pointed toe so will take some wearing in. Overall comfortable so far!
By Precise Shopper
Rated 4 out of 5
Would rather shop in person
I am usually a 7W. I sized up to a 7.5W after reading reviews (and out of fear of having to send them back!).
They’re a little bit too big, though a 7 may have been too small.
Overall, cute, comfy, and wide enough for my feets.
By NickSim
Rated 4 out of 5
Sharp pump
This is a sharp pump and it seems to be well made. I subtracted one star because despite the low heel it seems to be slightly less comfortable than some of my other Naturalizer shoes for some reason, possibly because of the very pointy toe. I ordered an 8.5, half a size up from my usual size 8 (other brands--I find all Naturalizer shoes run a bit small), and probably could have worn a 9. Still, Naturalizer is my go to brand for dress shoes and I wouldn't put anything else on my foot!
Rated 5 out of 5
I bought these in both black and creme brulee. They are the most comfortable heels I've ever worn and they look great. I just wish that these would also come in a more neutral beige/tan. The creme brulee is nice but a bit on the pink side so not as versatile as a true beige/tan would be.
By LawyerLovesShoes
Rated 4 out of 5
Very comfortable shoes, all the shoes that I bought here in naturatlizee is very good product comfy is excellent.
By Elle08
Rated 5 out of 5
Perfect dress shoe
Naturalizer has come through yet again. These shoes fit my narrow feet perfectly! I wore them for about 5 hours on a night out and my feet were not sore at all. I have fibromyalgia so comfort is important. These deliver comfort without giving up a nice look! The quality feels like what I've come to expect with this company. The height is perfect for someone who wants an upscale look without pain.
By Bsama
Rated 5 out of 5
Best pumps
These are my third pair. I have worn these pumps for years and replace them when needed with the same pair. These shoes can be worn straight out of the box without the need to break them in. I can wear these shoes 10 hour days without issue. Highly recommend
By LD2026
Rated 5 out of 5
Great Staple Shoe
I needed a comfortable black pump in my life. I had a job interview and realized I needed something comfortable classic, and versatile. These pulled through and I’m happy to own them.
By ShanJB
Rated 5 out of 5
Comfortable, dependable, runs large
Bought this in black leather, it's a good standard black pump. Very comfortable as I have come to expect from any Naturalizer shoe. Echoing some other reviews that this shoe runs large. I'm typically a 7.5W and had to size down to 7W.
By puzzleplum
Rated 2 out of 5
Horrible fit for those with extra wide feet
I purchased the extra wide width option as my foot has expanded greatly after pregnancy. They were definitely not extra wide width. I can barely get my foot in and they’re extremely painful. I can’t size up because then the shoe would flop off my foot so I’m screwed. I needed them for a school interview and now I have to find something I already have in my closet because these cause me so much pain.
By Benzo
Rated 5 out of 5
Extra Wide and so comfortable!
I have always wanted to hear heels but I have a wide foot and could not wear heels. They are tight at 1st but now that I have worn them a few times I love them!
By 918tulsatime
Rated 5 out of 5
Stylish AND Comfortable!
I love the Everly heels by Naturalizer! I originally purchased them in the nude colour and then loved them so much that I ordered a pair in black as well! They’re stylish without having a super high heel that hurts your feet and the sole is very cushy - SO comfortable! I wear my Everlys with jeans and dresses and they suit both. They’re definitely worth the price you pay.
By Ashley88
Rated 4 out of 5
Comfortable
Comfortable but noticing that your size 20 shoes fit small
Rated 5 out of 5
Perfect heel for work
Fantastic! I wanted a black heel but not too high. These fit great. True to size
