Naturalizer Women's Kelly Mary Jane Flat

These red Mary Jane flats are exactly what I've wanted for a couple years now. This isn't a stiff or firm leather but a super soft and buttery leather. *Heads-up on sizing* These seem true to shoe size but the width is another matter. I've worn a Medium and very occasionally a Narrow width shoe my entire life. I ordered my usual shoe size in the Medium width and though the length was great, they were so tight it was painful just to try on. I exchanged for same size in a Wide width and they're perfect. If you typically wear a Wide width shoe, it's likely these won't be a comfortable shoe for you. But if you find that the width works for you, these are so comfortable and pretty!

I have such a hard time finding shoes that fit my feet (very wide near the toes, normal heel) and these are super comfortable and feel very secure on my foot. The extra wide width fits my wide toebox and the strap means that they don't feel like they're gonna fly off my heel. So often wide width shoes are made for elderly people whose entire foot is swollen, which means that the heel is too wide which results in them slipping off your foot when you walk. Not these babies! I bought them to wear with a suit and they look great. PS please make the cute colors in extra wide too

I found these online and was so excited. The color is spot on, they are genuine leather, they have silver hardware, and the price is right. When they arrived one of those things became untrue. What I thought was silver hardware in the picture is actually pale gold in reality. Nothing against it if this is your thing, but I personally despise this pale gold. Unfortunately, I'll be returning them slightly brokenhearted.

I can comfortably wear these all day. For several years I had plantar fasciitis and was in pain every day. After years of fancy sneakers/inserts, exercise, etc. these were my first pair of “normal” shoes. I really like them and have worn them to work all day without pain in the evenings or the next day. I’m not brave enough to wear them every day yet, but it’s been so nice to have a little variety.

I bought these 3 months ago and while they are super comfortable, they are definitely almost retired. The sole has started to separate from the leather where it creases when walking, the sole is also thinning- but I walk and stand more than most people. They’re cute and fit well (true to size) just lack some sole integrity, it’s not bad for the price but could be better.

Charming black Mary Jane flats will go perfect with everything from pointe pants to jeans to a ‘little black dress’. Very classic. I like that they have a clearly defined heel and not just a molded filled in bottom - it gives it a classier look. While not as comfortable as, say, my Birkenstock, they are as comfortable as I expected from a closed-in pair of leather flats from Naturalizer. Meaning I can walk around the office or out to dinner in comfort, but I won’t be walking 15,000 steps over the cobblestones of Paris. The fit is a little narrow and small, but again, pretty much what I expected from this style, and I am confident the soft leather will stretch a bit as they mold to my feet. O only gave a four because it would really be nice if the buckle was Velcro, but still had the look of an actual buckle. I’ve just gotten used to that with so many shoes now and having to actually buckle and unbuckle each time is a bit annoying.

Amazing purchase! Like other reviewers, I find these comfortable, incredibly cute, on trend, and a great price. I originally bought these in my normal size, but went down a half size for a more snug fit since I’m wearing them with thinner socks. These are so comfortable that I wish they had them in the red velvet so I could buy more!

They do cramp my toes a bit but I think that’s just because of the size of the toe box. Could very well be just the shape of my foot idk but I’m not complaining tbh. They’re very comfortable otherwise. SUPER cute. Exactly what I was looking for. Very stylish. The materials used feel very high quality. Very true to size as well.